Staten Island, United States Real Estate Market

As of May 2026 in Staten Island, the market shows a steady balance between supply and demand. With 697 active listings and an average listing price of $858,623, buyers have a reasonable selection while sellers face moderate competition. Listings are not moving at an extreme pace, suggesting a cooling from peak activity, yet demand remains durable due to local economic factors and ongoing interest from buyers seeking value in a borough with varied neighborhoods and price points.



Buyers can anticipate continued negotiation opportunities and a willingness from sellers to entertain reasonable offers, especially on properties that have been on the market for several weeks. While inventory is not abundant, a measured approach and flexibility on terms may yield favorable results for qualified buyers in the Staten Island market going into mid-2026.



Investors may find selective opportunities in well-priced assets with strong rental potential or value-add improvements. The balanced market environment suggests gradual cap rate compression may occur as competition stays moderate; continuing to monitor neighborhood fundamentals, rental demand, and property condition will be key to identifying assets with solid long-term returns.